One of our Committee members, Muriel Davidson requested others to join
with her in putting together a submission to the Expert Panel on Access to
Historical Records. The main thrust of
her submission was to deal with genetically inherited diseases. Her support documentation included email
sent to her by others who have been affected by Genetically Inherited Diseases.
GENETICALLY
INHERITED DISEASES
Submission
to the Expert Panel on Release of Historic Census Records
Prepared
by Muriel M. Davidson
April
20, 2000
Esteemed Members of the Expert Panel:
Re:
Genetically Inherited Diseases Submission
Many family researchers have found potential “time bombs” in the familial data they have collected. I have been one of these researchers, and
suggested a combined submission about Genetically
Inherited Diseases. Many have
submitted suggestions, and I have tried to include a cross-section of known
inherited diseases.
We have used all sources of proven and true research papers, and all
agree the only true picture of the lives of our ancestors is within the Canadian
census records. We are very
anxiously and hopefully awaiting the release of the 1911 records in 2003 - we
only wish we would be able to view later census records within a short time for
medical reasons.
Families with inheritable diseases/genes live from day to day - one
never knows when the disease will pounce again … that is the way we feel.
The internet has provided much information about ALS, Q-T Syndrome,
Paget’s Disease, Alzheimer’s, Osteoporosis, Depression, Diabetes and others -
but it is the daily personal living in fear, not knowing how far back the
defective gene was in action.
Personally, I was fortunate to have family history from my grandfather;
he gave me information as he knew it, and I have found he was correct. Ironically, I am unable, at the present
time, to learn the information my grandfather provided for the 1911 Census.
Citizens of Canada, plus many with Canadian roots, anxiously await your
report. We sincerely hope all members
of the Expert Panel will be in favour of census release, not just for family
trees, but for important medical records. Being able to provide our doctors with
substantiated records would save long waiting periods prior to a diagnosis, as
happened to my youngerst brother, now 61, a victim of Multiple Sclerosis for 37
years.
Many thanks for working as members of this very important committee.
Sincerely,
Muriel M. Davidson
Family researchers, searching for roots of their past, became aware of
the possible non-release of Post-1901 Canadian census records years ago. In
1993, when the 1901 Canadian census was released, the fact was re-emphasized it
might be the last release. The 1901
Canadian census records were the first to include dates of birth, adding to
one's family history.
It was not until I became an internet user in November 1998 that I learned the
full extent of the governmental problem. It was evident that, unless records
were released for family research -- not just for governmental statistical
records - the Canadian public would lose 100 years of their history.
Canadian census records concern all residents of Canada, as well as many from
other countries who have Canadian roots. As one of many family researchers
poring over various types of documents, I have found there are none as
historically correct as our census records, thus forming a glowing montage of
life years ago.
There have been protests against release of records for family research --
citing both Privacy and Statistics Acts. Due to family pride taught by my
grandfather, I feel very certain he would be pleased I could hopefully learn
the information he gave the government in 1911.
Personal Research
My personal research for over forty years include much more than money earned
or bushels of wheat. Research for my family has also included United States
census records of 1900, 1910, 1920 and extracts from 1930 as my mother and her
sisters were born in Maine.
My main requirements are locality, names, ages, origins, religion, occupation
and, if given, medical data.
Questions asked by enumerators on the 1911 census included categories of deaf,
dumb, blind, insane, disabled also employed or unemployed. The answers to some
of these questions have to be painstakingly gathered and recorded. These same
answers and records affect many today as we check for unknown and possibly
inherited diseases.
Genetically Inherited Diseases
Genetically Inherited Diseases, in my belief, are medical problems/genes which
have appeared in two or more generations. In some families and diseases, the
problem may not show in successive generations, thus becoming known as a
"skipper".
These diseases are the cause of much heartache in many families, as they have
been in mine. I have heard from many via internet during the past 12 months,
telling their personal family tragedies.
My Personal Family Records
The following are my personal record of Genetically Inherited Diseases -- my
reason for desiring release of 1911 and subsequent Canadian census records. My
avenues of research have included past census records releases, church and
funeral home records and obituaries. Other documents include legal papers
including deeds, wills, administration of estate -- my files are open to all
concerned family members.
Some have remarked that "we are never given any problem we cannot
handle". It does take effort to
keep smiling with the record of Genetically Inherited Diseases in my own
personal family.
Multiple
Sclerosis
I first learned about this disease, although called by another name,
while researching the Loyalist family history of my gr.gr.gr.grandfather,
Finley McIntosh. He was a member of the
76th Regiment of Foot, native of Glenelg, Scotland, arrived in Shelburne, Nova
Scotia on November 5, 1783, following disbandment in New York City.
Finley McIntosh died in 1824, according to church records. Although his estate
was not very much compared to today's standards, his death was well-documented
by various papers. I have found a will, probate papers, letters of
administration, plus others.
The most valuable document was a Request to Administer the estate by a son,
William McIntosh. The reason given was:- His mother, the former Christiana
Brown, also from Glenelg, Scotland, was aged, infirm, with a severe paralytic condition. Her death
is recorded in church records of
1829. This was my first indication of a possibly known and documentable
medical condition.
Creeping Paralysis
The next known family member with this disease, by now known as "creeping
paralysis", was my great-aunt Alice Farquhar, my grandfather's
sister. Recorded printed data filed at
former Public Archives of Nova Scotia, states an unknown supplier of data
submitted the information that my great-aunt had been "crossed in
love" by her lover, took to her bed, stayed there for 30 years until she
died. This was very untrue, as the family members received help from the
so-called lover and his wife, as nursing care was greatly needed.
Multiple Sclerosis
My youngest brother, Clyde R. Farquhar, now 61, was a tall, slim man, 6'
2" in height, 40 years ago. He was studying to be a chartered accountant,
which he achieved and formed his own company. Clyde had never limped, had been
lieutenant of his Army Cadet Corps. On one vacation to my home province, Nova
Scotia, 39 years ago, I met his wife-to-be - but also noticed my brother
limped. When questioned, he replied "I always walk this way". Clyde
and Ruth married, followed by his collapse two weeks later. Ruth's brother, a
medical doctor and hemaetologist, knew of my family concerns. He received
positive results for the Multiple
Sclerosis tests 37 years ago.
Today, Clyde is wheelchair-bound, but continues to help others by testing new
drugs. When he has a physical at
Victoria General Hospital site, Queen Elizabeth II Health Science Centre,
Halifax, Nova Scotia, he is linked by computer to seven leading medical
facilities in the United States and Canada. Therefore, his doctor receives
guidance from Johns Hopkins, Mayo Clinic and others of that note. Clyde had
lost his ability to speak -- among drugs he had tested was one that allowed him
to regain control of his throat and speech muscles. I had not heard my brother's voice until he called me as a
birthday present last October -- saying "I'm back!" As he can no longer have life insurance, he
invests in real estate in Halifax, with all rentable properties insured and his
oldest son as manager.
Brain Tumors
My tabulated family history of brain tumors only covers 40 years. The list includes people of various ages and
seems to be a maternal disease pattern.
One of my mother's sisters lost two babies -- both with brain tumors. A brother and his wife lost one little boy,
age 13 months - same illness.
The latest to succumb to a brain tumor was my oldest brother, Donald S.
Farquhar, 73, died July 6, 1999.
Diagnosis was at Victoria General Hospital, Halifax, in 1998, but due to
lack of province-to-province transfer of patients, he was kept waiting for
several months. An operation was impossible. Laser treatment was available at
London Health Science Centre, London,
Ontario -- the Red Cross Society took care of his travel arrangements
and housing - again, due to lack of province-to-province patient transfer.
During the last few months of his life, the necessary wheelchair and hospital
bed cost a great deal - paid by the family.
Macular
Degeneration
This irreversible eye condition leads to blindness -- again from my
maternal family. One aunt, now 98,
blind from macular degeneration, hopes to "SEE" her name on the 1911
Canadian census records -- she was born in Bucksport, Maine in 1902.
My annual eye checkup includes a check for macular degeneration -- regarded by
my doctor, a well-known Brampton eye specialist, as an inheritable disease.
Cancer
There have been too many cases of this dreaded disease - from both
maternal and paternal families. Many family members have suffered various forms
of this illness.
Now 75, my first diagnosis was at the age of 21 -- malignant growth to the
appendix such as my mother also had at age 21, my daughter at 13. I was 42 when
cancer struck again. At present my facial cancer was diagnosed six years ago
with facial chemotherapy and periodic consultations.
Other familial forms of cancer have included liver, spinal, bowel - but not
breast cancer. It is similar to a giant octopus, of which we should be aware,
never knowing the next victim.
Arthritis
and Osteoporosis
Arthritis seems to have appeared in every family, to more than one person. Some
of the arthritic problems are very severe - hampered by non-funding of some
drugs in Ontario, e.g. Celebrex and Methothrexate. Non-funding of Fosamax in
Ontario for osteoporosis is a disadvantage to all old age pensioners.
Paget's Diseases include some of
the above: multiple sclerosis, osteoporosis, arthritis -- there is a great deal
on the internet re: this subject.
Diseases
in Adoptions
Not all Genetically Inheritable Diseases are passed down from
generation to generation -- but unknown to the new parents of an adopted child,
the disease comes with the child, having been passed down in the child's
family. One brother and his wife adopted two children.
They adopted a boy at first -- no problems. The girl was only nine days old
when received, dressed in dirty, ragged clothing which my brother immediately
destroyed. Signs of behavioural problems were noted very early, these
accelerating as she grew older. After she married, her first baby girl was
adopted out in British Columbia, due to a supposedly mental problem. With care,
that child is now doing fine, attending university, age 22.
Her only son, now 19, became part of my family when he was four years old. He
was unable to colour pictures, needed toilet-training, and with study, I
learned his behaviour problems were the result of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. My
brother, the boy's grandfather, attempted to learn his
adopted daughter's origin - adoption files were closed even to psychiatrists.
The doctors had hoped to learn about my niece's real parentage. His mother has
since been diagnosed as having schziophrenia, now doing fine on medication.
Two Hopes For the Future
My youngest granddaughter, 21, knowing the family history, is studying toward a
career in medical research. Her hope is to assist with development of a blood
test that would show any Genetically Inheritable Diseases. A young couple,
contemplating marriage, could be tested, and if tests were positive, they could
still marry. However, the couple could decide not to have any
children -- thus ending a cycle of genetically inheritable diseases.
My only grandson, 19, knows he could possibly inherit the "skipper"
MS gene. He changed
his future plans from space engineer, like his father -- is now in his second
year of biology at Waterloo University and looks forward to being a research
doctor.
Recommendations
·A question to be
added (or substituted) to the 2001 census questions, asking for people to list
known Genetically Inheritable Diseases with a YES or NO. Reason:
The present question, " deaf, dumb, blind, insane" and others have
been criticized by many. Instead, should I find a YES to any one of these, it would be treated as an answer to a
possibly previously unexplained medical condition.
·At present
children being adopted are received in basically the WYSIWYG -- What You See Is What You Get -- manner and
adoption system. Complete medical
history of both father and mother (if possible), blood types, known genetically
inheritable diseases, should be part of the adoption process. Names of real parents, locality of birth are
NOT part of a medical history.
·Census records of
people in institutions of long term care:- Back in 1901 and 1911, also earlier,
many family members were admitted to "poor farms", county homes or
insane asylums. To my knowledge, there are no census records of these members
of a family -- they were locked away as if they never existed. Mental illness seems to be a taboo subject -
but one that needs diagnosis.
Summary
From coast to coast, members of the Expert Panel, appointed by The Honourable
John Manley, will find numerous families with Genetically Inheritable Diseases.
Many religious denominations now have sealed records, although a great deal of
information is available about any person through Access to Information.
Governmental committees have used all the personal information we are seeking.
The internet is filled with many family histories, with much more available
from the Mormons.
It is sincerely hoped family researchers will be given the "green
light" for 1911 and later census records. As a family researcher, I know
the census records are very accurate, and this would have depended on
information given by my grandparents and others.
The Canadian census records are our one true picture of life as it really was
92 years ago, an irreplaceable history of migration, family members,
occupations.
I look forward to hopefully being able to view the 1911 and other records.
Thanking you for your consideration, I remain,
Muriel M. Davidson, U.E.
The following letters formed
part of Muriel Davidson’s submission to the Expert Panel and were included with
permission of the senders. Those
letters copied here that identify the writers are also done so with permission. While the original submission to the Expert
Panel include identifying information, the names of some of the writers have
been withheld here by request
ALZHEIMER’S
DISEASE
By Don Nisbet
Subject: My Letter on Genetic Disease for the Expert
Panel
Dear Panel Members:
One year ago my sister and I
buried our mother. The feelings of loss when a parent dies are no doubt
familiar to those on the panel, but I believe the end of her life must have
seemed a blessing to my mother as it ended seven years of suffering and loss.
My
mother was another victim of Alzheimer's disease.
Watching my mother slowly
reduced from a healthy and independent woman looking forward to
enjoying the remaining years allotted her to a
confused and fearful person, stripped of dignity and spirit and with
seemingly no capacity to enjoy even the simplest things, was painful beyond description for those of us who loved
her. Only those who have gone through
it can possibly understand.
But our sadness would not have been unfamiliar to my mother. My
aunt manifested the symptoms of this illness six years before her and she had
to watch her suffering as well. In 1956
they buried their mother after years of coping with the burden of caring for my
grandmother during her long battle with that same terrible disease. Our grandmother carried her own memories of
the effects of Alzheimer's disease on a family as she, as the youngest
daughter, carried the responsibilities of caring for her own mother in the last
years of her life -- another victim of that disease.
I have since learned that I
have had great-uncles and great-aunts and cousins as well die from the effects
of this nasty form of dementia. It is
now beyond question that this disease is in some way being genetically handed
down in our family and the fate of my mother, grandmother, and
great-grandmother may very well be my
own.
There is but one hope for
myself and the younger members of our family: the cause of this form of
genetically transmitted Alzheimer's Disease must be found and research for a
cure must be pursued. I am doing what I can.
As a genealogist I have
undertaken the sometimes difficult and frustrating work of compiling my family
tree by gathering information from public, private, and family records and
memory and turning that family tree into a medical pedigree of sufficient detail
and depth that it will be useful as a
research tool for genetic scientists
seeking the causes and the cure of this terrible disease.
Such medical family trees
are the bedrock of research into the causes of almost every disease known to be
genetic in origin. Already large family
trees have proven the key to uncovering the genes that cause Huntington's
Chorea, Cystic Fibrosis, Muscular Dystrophy, and dozens of more common diseases
such as types of cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. Canada has been among the
leaders in this type of genetic research and many similar studies using family
trees are underway across the country. But
more needs to be done.
I am hoping to offer, with
the full knowledge and blessing of family members, our family tree to genetic
scientists studying familial Alzheimer's disease in the hope it will lead to
progress and bring future relief to the
tens of thousands of Canadians who face this disease. When my tree is converted to a medical pedigree all identifying
information is stripped from it making it anonymous so it may safely be shared
with the medical community. I fear the
disease more than I fear the remote possibility of my privacy being violated.
Compiling a family tree as
accurate and complete as I have done would not have been possible without
access to Canada's historical census records.
The loss of such future access will significantly damage both genealogy
and research into genetic diseases of that there is no doubt in my mind. I feel the privacy violation, if it can even
be remotely considered as such, of granting to historians and genealogists
access to census records after 92 years is little to ask for so large a gain.
I do not accept that the
supposed privacy when the rights of the dead take precedence over the right of
the living to enjoy healthy and productive lives.
I respectively ask the panel
not to forget the real consequences on the lives of hundreds of thousands of
Canadian men, women, and children suffering genetic diseases now and in the
future if historical censuses are closed or destroyed.
They
deserve a voice in this debate.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Don Nisbet
DEPRESSION
By Muriel M. Davidson
The weather is very damp and the sky is without a hint of sun! How often have we remarked or heard others
say the "day is depressing!"
However, as soon as the sun warms the earth, which lightens our moods,
the depressive feeling disappears. Many are not so fortunate as he or she
suffers from a disease caused by a possibly inherited gene, not the weather.
I am referring to an honest-to-goodness illness - clinical depression. This
disease, unrecognized by many, is probably the biggest single medical cause
behind most human sufferings and
illnesses. This condition strikes as many as one of every five persons. Very
often many who suffer from this common malady are undiagnosed. The victims of
this genetically inherited disease are generally regarded as strange, weird,
often unable to associate with others, which compounds and increases the
problem.
Personally I am one of the fortunate ones with diagnosis years ago. My
two sons have also been diagnosed, but my daughter did not inherit this gene,
nor did her children. There have been other family members known from previous
generations.
Sufferers of depression are all around us -- the homeless, the alcoholic, those
trying to survive within the confines of society. The ailment has no class distinction, is a genetically
inheritable
disease -- very often family doctors prescribe sedating medication.
There is still an age-old fear of psychiatrists -- often the patient is simply
not referred. Close relatives refuse to accept the family member is a victim of
an ancient gene, therefore not
realizing the psychological condition is treatable not only by suitable
medication, but mainly family understanding.
Many with clinical depression, unlike the gloomy day depressives, often
resort to alcohol, drugs, resorting to crime so more expensive drugs can be
obtained. This is the way of dealing with how he or she feels.
Many of the young people who commit suicide or fill our jails and prisons are
victims of this age-old mood inhibitor. Although many have a high degree of
intelligence, due to depression, they are unable to make friends, become loners
and eventually many do commit suicide.
The gene that causes clinical depression dates back to the cave age, is ancient
and is not a mutant gene. Depressed brains do not function properly, very often
there is a chemical imbalance. The
inability to function properly is similar to brain wires being cut --
preventing the transmission of emotions and rational thoughts. The victims feel empty, unable to think,
often unable to remain
employed. An example of non-functioning brain wires is the inability to send an
internet message when the server is unoperational.
Many family researchers have studied Canadian census records of 1871,
1881, 1891and 1901 -- we are grateful for some of the personal questions asked
by enumerators when it seems a family member "disappeared" -- yet
still living. Working with church records, we find there generally is NO
recorded trace of the relative's disappearance among our census records.
Years ago, in my family, as in many other families, family members were
admitted to the "county home" or "poor farm". with personal
family history denoting a mental disorder. This disorder was possibly a form of
depression -- unrecognized years ago.
The family members disappeared without a trace because census records WERE NOT taken of institutional
residents. Although alive, they were not included, unless residing in a
community and he or she were listed as having a mental disability. We are
thankful these intrusive questions were asked by the enumerators -- there is
acceptance in knowing.
My family members know I suffer from depression, have refused medication, but
prefer my own "treatment" -- keep busy and active. I have accepted depression, part of the
healing process - often reading or crocheting is better than routine household
chores.
Part of my personal treatment is a great deal of "people
contact":-
1. Coordinator of 150 knitters for Brampton Memorial Hospital maternity ward, a
volunteer position -- my daughter is my "boss".
2. Eight family history books researched, printed and filed at National
Archives.
3. Public relations for my Rebekah lodge, IOOF.
4. Recently serving as liaison for 31 local
Brampton service clubs with the local city newspaper, where I had been women's
editor. This is a challenge -- a
first!!
5. An active member of the internet-based Canadian Census Release Committee.
My two sons combat their depressive problems differently. The oldest son is in sales and
administration at a large motorcycle shop, races motorcycles and gets rid of
any nagging problems at the gym.
The youngest son, a long-distance truck driver, has a chemical imbalance. He
combats SADD by turning on lights to counteract lack of sun and Vitamin D, plus
medication.
In summary, many who suffer from depression could live a normal
community life through acceptance. People need to be accepted for "what
they can do" -- not "what they have". This is
one strong way of living with a disease that dates back to the early days of
mankind.
As an active member of the internet-based Canadian Census Release
Campaign, it is our sincere hope the Expert Panel will report favourably to
have the 1911 and future Canadian census
records made available for research by families faced with Genetically
Inheritable Diseases. Many are anxiously awaiting your report.
Thank you for serving on this appointed committee.
Sincerely,
Muriel M. Davidson
Clinical
Depression
Hi Muriel,
My name is Pat XXXXX, I live in Scotland and I suffer from inherited clinical
depression. Vicky XXXXX forwarded your e-mail to me as she knows about my
struggle with this condition.
Luckily, I now have a doctor who understands what is going on inside my head
and helps me through.
Depression exhausts me and leaves me like a zombie - I am unable to sleep or
function. However, I now know how to spot it before it really floors me and I
can take some preventative
action. The first thing I do is clean and tidy the house. That may seem a little strange but I get
very self-critical when depressed so I do what I can to eliminate the
triggers. Then I buy some novels so
that when I can't sleep, I have something new and interesting to read. After
that I fill
up the fridge and the freezer with tasty convenience foods because I know I
won't cook if things get bad and I need good fuel to get this machine (my body
and mind) working well again.
Sometimes after all that, the depression fails to take hold and I thank God.
More often than not, I do sink into that sticky black pit and then at least I
can hibernate in some comfort until it has passed.
Thankfully, it has been some weeks now since I have had a down spell. I know it
will return but I also know that it will pass and that keeps me going through
the bad times. I am blessed with great
friends and two wonderful children who carry me through. Without them, I would
find it much harder to bear.
I get very annoyed with people who don't understand depression and ask me what
I have to be depressed about.
Depression is not caused by external forces, it is in my genetic
make-up. That doesn't mean that I cannot do anything about the symptoms of
depression but I can't change the underlying condition.
Thank you for sharing your experience with me. This can be a very lonely
condition and, in my case, some of that loneliness is self inflicted because I
avoid company when I am down.
Keep well and busy. Know that you have friends all over the world with the same
problem and we are all fighting to overcome it in our own way.
With kind regards from a fellow depression fighter
Pat.
AVAILABLE
MEDICAL RECORDS
By Larry McCool
Your description of the way you live with Clinical Depression was very
moving. My wife, Doreen, is one of the people that was at the door of a full
breakdown before a doctor realized what was happening.
Early retirement as well as medication has done a lot to help -- but crowds are
still a very difficult situation. Availability of historical medical records
and the genealogical records that would be needed to tie the family together
would have, in all likelihood, either prevented the severity of this case or at
least forewarned us of the possibility of that type of sickness.
Along with that we now know that in my side of the family we go back to my
father and ahead to my grandchildren with diabetes. Earlier family members died
early, such as my grandfather
who we suspect had the dreaded disease.
Our latest patient is my granddaughter who was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes
at the age of three.
Keep smiling - we are behind you!
COMMENT RE APPROACH
Dear Muriel,
I have no criticisms to make about your essay on depression, but I do have to
say that I was most moved by it. It was a very brave thing to write this, and I
think that many people may benefit from reading it. I was especially delighted
to read your counter blast to the prevalent dominant approach to treatment with
nothing but chemicals.
Power to you,
Bob XXXXX
Calgary, AB
DEPRESSION
Muriel - your message was a powerful one..
As a fellow depression sufferer, although one who is helped by the new
serotonin reuptake inhibitors, I am beginning to understand the genetic factors
behind depression.
I was recently surprised to learn that my grandmother's sister most likely
committed suicide after the death of her daughter in a fire. It's impossible to
know if that's where the gene that keeps my serotonin level at less than
optimum levels was inherited, but it's a clue.
My eldest daughter has the same condition and is currently taking Zoloft while
I take Paxil. The difference these medications make is nothing short of magic
even at low dosages. But finding even circumstantial evidence of serious
depression in my family history helps us to understand that this isn't a
'character problem' as it was depicted for years, but an actual chemical
imbalance that is inherited and is probably the reason that I had suicidal
thoughts as young as 8 years old.
Thank goodness, those days are behind me but I lived with them for over 40
years.
Name withheld by request.
STRABISMUS
By Jack XXXXX
Hello Muriel:
My name is Jack XXXXX. The XXXXX family does not have congenital disease, but
does have a congenital defect - strabismus, or crooked eye. It usually is the
left eye, but occasionally it is of the wandering variety, in other words it
alternates from one eye to the other.
My youngest sister and I have it, but my oldest sister and my brother do not. I
know it has occurred in past generations, but I have not done any
investigations in that area.
Strabismus does affect the sight, as the inturned eye tries to compensate for
the defect so that you don't see double. If the child that is born with it is
operated upon prior to age 3 the sight can be saved.
If not operated on (to straighten the eye) the retina becomes dead where the
vision from the good eye overpowers the inturned eye. In my sister's case,
because it was alternating, the sight was not affected - she was operated on at
about age 13 or 14, and her eyesight is normal.
Jack XXXXX,
from the sunny Peace River area
of Beautiful British Columbia.
DIABETES
and PROLONGED Q-T SYNDROME
(Name Withheld)
To Members of the Expert Panel:-
In my family, maternally and paternally we have various genetically inherited
diseases. Paternally, we deal with adult onset diabetes and astigmatism.
Please be advised I am writing to ask for the Post 1901 censuses to be released
for the purpose of genealogical research by individuals and medical
professionals.
Diabetes has claimed the lives of several members of the --------- family. Most
recently, my great uncle in September 1999 and my father in November 1999. My
father fought with his diabetes for 30 years. It won, but during the battle, it
took his right leg, and part of his left foot.
The amputations were something he never recovered from.
The family has always been very athletic. Dad's grandfather was the trainer
that took the Regina Pats to the World Series in 1926. My father was a serious
roller skate dance skater who competed throughout Canada and the USA during the
1940's and 50's. It never ceases to amaze me, when watching ice skate
competitions, that my father could do what they did on roller skates. His love
for roller skating was passed on to his children. We were put on roller skates
as soon as we could walk.
I however, was never able to seriously pursue the sport. Due to the genetic
astigmatism in my family, I'm legally blind, I'm extremely farsighted, and was
cross-eyed (eye operations cosmetically corrected this, but failed to improve
my vision). My eyes work independently of
each other, impairing my co-ordination and depth perception. My sisters and a
paternal cousin also have minor vision problems, as does my son (including one
operation to correct the cross-eyedness).
It is interesting to note, I'm doing genealogical research on my paternal
family. Because of the public access to England's 1881 census, I have found a
-------- in a school for the blind. In the 1851 census, I found an unmarried
(not widowed) 74 year old female --------- living in a workhouse. The first
questions that popped into my mind upon discovering her: "Was she
blind/cross-eyed? Why had she never married?" She's listed as a pauper. I
know the taunting
I took for my eyes and we live in gentler times. She is the only --------
pauper I have found. Everyone else is employed in the family trades or a
widowed annuitant.
My older sister and younger sister are both diabetic. My younger sister's
diabetes is out of control, I haven't picked up this genetic trait from my
family. But, I did pick up my maternal line's genetically inherited disease.
Both my younger sister and I have it. Our sons are
borderline. The defect is called Prolonged Q-T Syndrome.
It causes Sudden Arythymic Death. The heart is healthy, but the auto response
nervous system is not. Our heart beat has trouble following a rhythm. An
ordinary pace maker would correct it. It is
one cause of Sudden Infant Death. Thankfully, it is extremely rare. In the USA 25,000 people have been diagnosed
with it out of a population of over 250 million.
Q-T syndrome is silent and deadly in most families afflicted with it. It is usually diagnosed after it has killed
within a family. Even then, it is often missed as you can't do an ECG on a dead
person. Q-T often strikes apparently healthy children and young adults. Imagine
your child dropping dead while running a race in a school sports day, or
running home to share a triumph or trauma. Will the excitement of a wedding day
or birth lead to a funeral? The
startling noise of a thunder clap can kill in my family. We, those who are
diagnosed are allowed no physical or emotional exertion.
I am not allowed to swim. If I faint in the ocean, I die. I'm not even allowed
to drink Neo-Citran for a cold. I have to be careful when I go to the dentist
and make sure that certain anaesthetics are not used. There is a large list of
prescription drugs I'm not allowed, I have to read over the counter medicines
to make sure they won't kill me, or possibly my children. I look and feel
healthy, but I'm not. Walking upstairs can exhaust me. I can break into a sweat
washing dinner
dishes. I was born in 1953. There is not a lot of things I can do, things I
would love to experience with my 4 year old daughter.
But, you know what I can do is sit at my computer using large fonts so I can
see to trace my maternal ancestry. By following bloodlines I will be able to
warn them there maybe a silent, swift killer lurking in their branch. I know
not to startle them with a blunt revelation, but to ask about fainting/dizzy
spells (syncope) and if given a positive response or told of a young person's
death to carefully advise my new found relative to go see a cardiologist.
There is no cure for Q-T. Its victims survive on pills, and if that fails to
stop the syncope the result is an implant of a cardioverter/defibulator. Your very own little personal CPR unit. I'm
supposed to have someone who knows CPR with me at all times. I'm being
monitored by my
cardiologist and I'm on a wait list for the implant.
I'm one of the lucky ones. My mother wasn't so lucky. She died at the age of 46
from a heart attack. It is her diagnosis, that may be saving my life. I think
she would be happy to know, I'm trying to find her relatives to warn them. The
public release of the 1906 and 1911 censuses will help me find them. The family
oral history is her father's family has been in Canada for five generations. My
grandfather was born there. How many siblings did he have? Where are they? I
don't know. The censuses will tell me. Has Q-T been passed into your family? Wouldn't you want the warning?
I had time to prepare for my father's death. There was no warning with my
mother. Both were traumatic for me. From honest experience, the sudden death
was harder to take and adjust to, particularly for my younger sister who was
only 17 when Q-T hit our immediate family.
With the British Columbia vital statistics, birth, marriage and death online, I
have been able to find that my maternal grandfather was married prior to his
marriage to my maternal grandmother. I may need to trace half relatives.
Surname BROOKS. Did my grandfather have more than one child? The 1911 census
will tell me.
Please give my family a fighting chance to survive by supporting the public
release of the Post 1901 censuses. Thank you for listening.
Sincerely
Name withheld by request.
FABRY'S
DISEASE
Lloyd A. Horrocks, Ph.D.,
Professor Emeritus
Hi Muriel,
One inherited disease of particular interest is Fabry's disease, which has a
focus on Tancook Island, Lunenburg County, Nova Scotia, and should be included.
The island is a perfect place for familial research due to the constant
residency pattern.
Fabry's disease is a disorder with an enzyme missing for processing a
particular kind of fat that is on the membranes of cells.
I used to talk about this in lectures to medical and graduate students (before
I knew that I had ancestors from Tancook Island!).
Let me know if you need more information.
Lloyd A. Horrocks, Ph.D., Professor Emeritus
Dept. of Molecular & Cellular Biochemistry, The Ohio State University
The purpose of this text is to provide patients and their families with
information about the symptoms, diagnosis, management, and experimental
treatment of Fabry disease.
In 1898, two dermatologists, Johann Fabry in Dortmund, Germany and William
Anderson in London, England, independently described the first patients with
the disorder now known as Fabry disease. Forty years later, it was recognized
that the disease resulted from abnormal
deposits of a particular fatty substance (known as lobotriaosylceramide) in
blood vessel walls throughout the body. In the 1960's, the primary defect was
identified as the inherited deficiency of the enzyme, -galactosidase A, which
is normally responsible for the breakdown of
globotriaosylceramide. The gene for this enzyme was isolated and characterized
in 1986 at Mount Sinai, permitting improved diagnosis, especially of female
carriers, and the capability to produce large amounts of the normal enzyme for
trials of enzyme replacement therapy.
What Is the Nature of the Metabolic
Defect in Fabry Disease?
The body performs thousands of metabolic processes which are necessary for the
production of vital compounds and the recycling or removal of others. One such
compound called globotriaosylceramide is formed of three sugars and a fatty
substance called ceramide, and is found in most cells of the body. Normally globotriaosylceramide is broken
down (metabolized)
to lactosylceramide by the enzyme -galactosidase A. In patients with Fabry
disease, this enzyme does not function properly or is absent, and
globotriaosylceramide cannot be broken down in
cells, leading to its progressive accumulation.
Thus, Fabry disease is often referred to as a "storage disorder"
because of the abnormal accumulation of globotriaosylceramide. In patients with Fabry disease,
globotriaosylceramide accumulates preferentially in the walls of blood vessels.
As the abnormal storage of this fatty compound increases with time, the
channels of these vessels become narrowed, leading to decreased blood flow and
decreased nourishment of the tissues normally fed by these vessels.
This process occurs in all blood vessels throughout the body, but particularly
affects small vessels in the skin, kidneys, heart, and nervous system.
How Is Fabry Disease Inherited?
Fabry disease is an inherited disorder. The defective gene is on the
X-chromosome, which is one of the two chromosomes that determine an
individual's sex. Females have two X chromosomes, one inherited from each of
their parents. Males have one X chromosome inherited from their mothers and one
Y chromosome inherited from their fathers. A female Fabry carrier has one X
chromosome with a defective Fabry gene and one X chromosome with the normal
gene, and thus is protected from the major manifestations of the disease. Males
with Fabry disease have one X-chromosome that contains the abnormal gene and
thus, show symptoms of the disease.
The inheritance pattern of Fabry disease is termed "X-linked recessive
inheritance." A female carrier of Fabry disease has a 50% chance of
transmitting the defective Fabry gene to her sons
who will develop Fabry disease. In addition, she has a 50% chance of
transmitting the Fabry gene to her daughters who will be carriers like their
mother. It must be emphasized that these risk figures apply to each pregnancy
individually, that is, for each male child there is a 50% chance to have the
disease, and for each female child there is a 50% risk to be a carrier.
If a male with Fabry disease and an unaffected (non-carrier) female
have children, all of their daughters will be Fabry carriers and none of their
sons will be affected with Fabry disease.
Fabry disease occurs in all ethnic groups. It is estimated that one
person in 40,000 has the disease.
How does Fabry disease affect males?
Typically, the disease begins in childhood with episodes of pain and discomfort
in the hands and feet (known as acroparesthesias). The painful episodes may be brought on by exercise, fever,
fatigue, stress, or change in weather conditions. In addition, young patients
develop a spotted, dark red skin rash (known as angiokeratoma) seen most
densely from the umbilicus to the knees, a decreased ability to perspire, and a
characteristic change on the cornea of the eye that does not affect
vision.
The disease progresses very slowly and symptoms of kidney, heart and/or
neurologic involvement occur between the ages of 30 to 45. In fact, many
patients are first diagnosed when the accumulated storage material begins to
affect kidney or heart function. Therefore, it is important to annually monitor
kidney function by blood and urine tests because kidney disease is a major
complication that can occur in affected males.
A common heart symptom in Fabry patients is mitral valve prolapse, which is a
benign condition that is present in approximately 10% of the normal population.
More serious, but rarer, complications
of Fabry disease include heart disease and strokes.
To Members of the Expert Panel
I have two brothers with a disease that the doctors say is passed on in
the family. My oldest brother has had
this since age 6 weeks and is 47 now.
The family has many times been told because of the high temps and
swollen spleen and all the rest that he would not make it through the night.
He spent most of his young life in hospital and away from home. He was a medical ? in Canada and the United
States til he turned about 18 years old.
My other brother started with differing symptoms and was diagnosed
later in teem years. Both are under
treatment and will be all their life when an attack occurs and we are looking
for where and when in the gene pool this was introduced.
They say of all who have this it can be traced to Jewish
background. It could have been way back
when but it could have been within 100 years.
This is what got me started on tracing family history and I am
staggered at the opposition to release of census due to the stumbling blocks
that it puts in front of me. It is hard
enough researching and hitting brick walls.
I understand the dilemma because of working the census for over 25
years but a date of 100 years would be sufficient for protection of
material. Just how many live beyond
100? A few - but I am sure the ones
that do would not worry as that is the past.
Sincere regards,
Name withheld by request.
Dear Muriel:-
Thank you Muriel for your note.
It was very touching to me & very kind of you to write & tell me
you enjoyed the posting on the Wells family mailing list. I’m glad it was forwarded on to you.
My father died 10 years ago from ALS, which I believe is a form of
Multiple Scheroses & it was really hard to see him go to such a terrible
disease in such a short time & knowing there was nothing I could do to stop
it. Sometimes we just don’t understand
why God lets these terrible things happen to such good people.
After some time passed I started searching my family history to learn
about my ancestors & also to try to find out infor on the causes of deaths
of not only his family but my mother’s too.
I wanted to have another child but did not want to pass on a bad gene to
another generation. I was told by my
family doctor there was no way of know if I was a carrier back then, if I had a
son then the chances might be higher. I
had a daughter but the thought never goes away. She will never know the love & kindness of her grandfather
but she is my sunshine.
My dad would have loved the treasure hunt I have been on looking for
infor on his XXXXX family, not just for the medical infor but for the family
history & tracing them back in time to learn more about their lives &
the times they lived in. I don’t find
any such illness in his line but it was not known by that name many generations
ago.
I didn’t share this story with the mailing list - my father wasn’t from
the Wells family but I couldn’t help post the note to let others know the
importance of learning their family medical history if not for themselves then
to do it for the sake of their children.
My father-in-law had diabetes & he has passed away a few years
ago. His mother lost both her legs from
it & now my brother-in-law- found out he also had it a year ago & and
has lost a foot due to it. I have had
my husband checked & my ofdest daughter checked & will always keep that
in mind in the future to watch for the signs so we can catch it early.
I just hope others will be aware of learning more about their medical
history & discuss it with their family doctors. The more we learn about our medical history the better we can
help the doctors to treat our families.
Thanks again for your note &
Happy trails in all your researching in 2000
Name withheld
AMYOTROPHIC LATERAL
SCLEROSIS (ALS)
Internet
Information from
ALS
Society of Canada
<alscanada@als.ca>
ALS is a rapidly
progressive, fatal neuromuscular disease. It attacks the motor neurons
responsible for transmitting electrical impulses from
the brain to
the voluntary muscles
throughout the body. When these muscles fail to receive messages, they
eventually lose strength,
atrophy and die. There is no
known treatment.
Anyone can get ALS. Over
3,000 Canadians currently have the disease. Two to three
Canadians die every day of ALS.
Why is it known as Lou
Gehrig's Disease?
Lou Gehrig, a famous
baseball player in the U.S. during the 1930's, became afflicted with ALS. He
was known as baseball's "Ironman". Strength, agility, excellent
health - Lou Gehrig had everything it took to become a baseball legend. But Lou Gehrig had something else. At the peak of his career, he was diagnosed
as having Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis
(ALS). He died at the age of 38.
When was ALS first
discovered?
ALS was first
described in 1869 by Jean-Martin Charcot, a French neurologist. Since that time
a number of theories about the cause of ALS
have been developed. Some scientists believe it is possible that ALS is caused by a slow-acting or latent "virus". If it is caused by
an organism, there is absolutely no fear that it is contagious. There is no increased incidence among
medical personnel who deal with ALS
patients. Work has also been done on
the possible role of the thyroid gland and trauma.
What causes ALS?
The cause is not yet known although several theories are now being
researched. At present neither a cure for ALS
nor a means of prevention is known. In 1993, scientists announced in a paper
published in the British journal "Nature" that they had isolated the
gene associated with about 20% of the cases of the inherited form of the
disease. While only 10% of ALS
patients have this genetic predisposition there is no evidence of a clinical
difference between the familial and the sporadic forms of the illness.
What about environmental
causes?
The very high incidence of ALS
on the island of Guam, in Western New Guinea and on Kii peninsula of Japan may
provide some clues about environmental influences. Heavy metals such as lead
and mercury are suspected causes, as is aluminum, which can poison the body and
cause ALS symptoms. Some people may
have a genetic makeup which makes them susceptible to an environmental cause of
ALS.
What parts of the body does
it affect?
Because it attacks only motor neurons, ALS does not affect the mind.
The person with ALS remains mentally sharp and in full possession of the senses
of sight, hearing, taste, smell and touch. Bladder and bowel muscles are
generally not affected by ALS. ALS seldom causes pain, although some people do
have cramps and secondary discomfort from lengthy sitting or lying down.
Is sexual function affected
by the disease?
No.
Are there different types of
ALS?
There are three classifications:
Sporadic (which is the
most common form of ALS)
Familial (a small number
of cases suggest genetic inheritance of ALS)
Guamanian (a high number
of cases of ALS occur in Guam and
the Trust Territories of the
Pacific)
What are the early symptoms
of ALS?
ALS usually becomes
apparent either in the throat or upper chest area or in the arms and legs. Some
people begin to trip and fall; some lose the use of their hands and arms; some
find it hard to swallow and some slur their speech.
Can you "catch"
ALS? And what does it do?
ALS cannot be
"caught" - it is not contagious. In 90% of ALS cases, it strikes
people with no family history of the disease. Ten percent of the cases are
classified as familial or inherited ALS.
It may occur at any age, with the likelihood increasing as people grow
older. However, many are struck down in
the prime of life. ALS occurs
equally in men and women.
Because the disease frequently takes its toll before being positively
diagnosed, many patients are debilitated before learning they have contracted ALS. The disease does not affect the
senses of taste, touch, sight, smell and hearing, or the mind.
ALS wreaks a
devastating effect on patients as well as their families. As they struggle to
cope with the prospect of advancing disability and death, it consumes their
financial and emotional reserves. It is a costly disease in its later stages,
demanding both extensive nursing care and expensive equipment.
Is there hope for people
with ALS?
Yes, certainly. Based on recent medical discoveries, drug trials are
now underway. Advances in our knowledge
about other neurological diseases may also continue to shed light on the cause
of ALS and help us find a cure.
What is the incidence of
ALS? How many people in Canada are affected?
It is not a rare disease, anyone can get it. It affects about six or
seven people out of every 100,000. Over
3,000 Canadians currently have ALS.
Two to three Canadians die every day of ALS. Most people with ALS are between the ages of 50 and 75 though there are cases of
teenagers with the disease. In about 5-10% of cases of ALS there is a hereditary pattern.
About 90-95% of cases are "sporadic" ALS: anyone can be affected. This can occur at anytime within two
to five years of diagnosis.
What is the average life
expectancy?
This is between two and three years for the newly diagnosed person.
However, it is important to understand that improved medical care is resulting
in longer and more productive lives for people with ALS. Twenty percent will
live more than five years and up to 10% will survive more than ten years.
For further information:
<http://www.als.ca/alsWHAT.htm>
BREAST
CANCER
By
Ricki-Ann XXXXX
My name is Ricki-Ann XXXXX. I
am an American Citizen with Canadian roots. I began
to do my family history as a way to relieve stress and became addicted to it.
Through access to
Canadian records, particularly census records, I am
able to trace my lineage further and
further back. The census records
provided me with a wonderful starting point
from which I have gathered much information about my family's heritage
and history.
I have also uncovered
information about medical causes of death of several blood
relatives. It seems "cancer" and/or "cancer of the breast" are a
lot closer to home than I ever
thought.
This information scared
me, but prompted
me, at the age of 32 to get my
first mammogram, when under normal circumstances it isn't even suggested
until after age 40. By age 40 it may have been too late. There were
abnormalities in the mammogram.
I now go for follow-ups
every 3-6 months at my physician's
request to track any changes, and keep ahead of the
"abnormality".
If I had never found my great great-grandmother's name, I would have
never found the names of her family, or theirs, or the "abnormality".
I am deeply grateful to
access of such records as census
information, and truly believe it may just
save my life.
Breast cancer does "run"
in my family, there is
some genetic link, and now I am
aware. Awareness is half the battle.
Preventing access
to such records
may prevent others
from the advanced warning that I received. That
would be tragic.
Respectfully
Ricki-Ann XXXXX
USA